background
The war in Iraq, called Operation Iraqi
Freedom
by
the United States, began
in March, 2003 under the
administration of American President George W. Bush and United Kingdom
Prime Minister Tony Blair.
There has been much controversy surrounding the motives for the initial
invasion, as the suspected weapons of mass destruction, WMDs, that were
used to justify the mission were reported a year
later to not exist
there. President Bush gave a
speech
on May 1, 2003, wherein he declared: “My fellow Americans, major
combat operations in Iraq have ended. In the battle of Iraq, the United
States and our allies have prevailed.” This speech was
given less than two months after the beginning of conflict, and now,
more than seven years later, the war is ongoing - with death counts
in the thousands every year. A large majority of these deaths
have occurred in the city of Baghdad (see following chart), which is
why we have
chosen Baghdad as the site of our project.

Within Baghdad, the majority of these deaths are civilian (see below) which is highly problematic, and we feel, warrants further investigation.

Deaths in Baghdad
| Civilian Deaths |
Total Deaths |
| 22,349 | 29,467 |
The civilian deaths in this war have been
momentous. One simple reason to explain the high
count of civilian deaths is the fact that war efforts were concentrated
in a highly populated area, and many war-related deaths occured in
residential areas (though there are also much more complex theories on
why there is a high civilian death rate). The following chart
illustrates the magnitude of this war's impact on civilian life by
outlining civilian deaths per day in Iraq, by year:
| Year |
Civilian Deaths Per Day |
| 2003 | 1.4 |
| 2004 | 5.2 |
| 2005 | 9.9 |
| 2006 |
16.0 |
| 2007 | 21.0 |
| 2008 | 10.0 |
| 2009 | 8.2 |
| 2010 | 7.5 |
Source: Iraq Body Count
These are extremely high numbers,
especially for a topic that rarely reaches mainstream media.
These deaths occur all over Iraq, but are concentrated in Baghdad, and
many occur in residential areas. Because of the following
statistics, we decided to focus part
of our project on residential areas as sites of war activity.
|
|
Deaths in Residential Road Buffers |
Deaths in Other Areas of Baghdad |
| Civilian |
7,841 (35%) |
14,508 (65%) |
| Total Deaths |
9,523 (32%) | 19,944 (68%) |
International war laws
such as the
Geneva
Convention regarding
both the treatment of prisoners of war (POW’s) and also the protection
of
civilians has been largely violated, indicated by the staggering
civilian death count and news reports of
prisoner mistreatment. While millions
have protested over the
seven years of this ongoing war, there
was, at least initially, much support from the American people to carry
through with this mission. A poll
published by CNN in 2007, however,
declared that only 30% of Americans supported the war, indicating a
downward trend the longer the engagement went on.
Scandals such as detainee
torture
have added to this skepticism and, in a way, tarnished the war’s
credibility. While these facts are but snapshots of much larger
issues, the purpose
of the inclusion of this information is to illustrate the hotly
contested nature of the Iraq war.
Another consequence of this
war is the
large scale
displacement that has occurred in Iraq. Millions
have fled their homes
for safer areas,
living in increasingly desperate conditions. Many of those leaving the
city of Baghdad have reported
to be professionals, including 22,000 physicians.
Ethnic conflicts that had previously been relatively quiet have surged
in violence throughout the war. As Dr. Derek Gregory writes in
his
paper, Biopolitics
of Baghdad,
Though this phenomena is incredibly interesting and the source of much current research, it was not a dimension included in the maps due to limitations of finding accurate data of ethnic concentrations, especially of a practical scale. The maps published of this data are exemplified by this one, created by The Times (UK):

These maps
demonstrate the difficulties we faced in accessing data at a scale
accurate enough to project spatially. The above map (and others like
it) would be too imprecise when digitized to meaningfully represent
spacial distributions of ethnicity. However, ethnic conflict is
an important dimension of
the war, and while it is impossible to define any one cause, there is
evidence that they have at least been exacerbated by the presence of
war. Therefore, it is possible that some of the deaths classified
as civilian included in this study are related to this ethnic conflict,
but for reasons outlined above, they are included in the count as war
deaths.
Studies published by
the Brookings
Institute Iraq Index have indicated a
decrease in quality of life in the years following the start of the
war, characterised by indicators such as daily
hours of electricity accessible to homes, and access to clean water and
sewage. As Human Geography majors, our awareness of these issues
and interest
in visualizing the presence of this war, and its negative effects on
daily life for citizens of Baghdad has led us to embark on this
project. Another reason for our interest in this subject is that
we feel that due to the length of this war, public interest and
awareness of Iraq war issues have waned over time, and we hope that our
visualization contributions through mapping will be important tools for
an
increase of that awareness and interest. The well-timed release
of the Wikileaks
Iraq War data,
facilitated an opportunity for us to visualize this important data. The
data set is comprised of more than 52,000 individual confidential
records of death ‘events’ which resulted in anywhere from 1 - 443
deaths, Previous to the release of this data, at least 15,000
civilian deaths had been secretly reported by
the US Military in Baghdad, but not listed or published.
The US Military has criticized Wikileaks, calling the release “dangerous” and claiming that the leak has “endangered the lives of US forces and people who support US forces around the world.” However, this reaction can also be seen as a result of embarrassment, as there has been an increase in criticism of the US Military since the release of these documents (because of misrepresentations of deaths and underreporting, a video of US soldiers killing journalists and civilians, and secret codes admitting to the knowledge of detainee torture practices have been unearthed in the process). As the Wikileaks data used in this project was confidential documents that were not intended for release, we felt it was a necessity to utilize this data to create physical records of these deaths. The discrepancy between what was reported to the media and what was recorded in these files was another important factor in why we felt the need to visualize it. In the process of creating a visual and tangible record of all of the deaths in Baghdad, these maps serve to hold the war, and specifically, the opposing forces, accountable for these deaths.* (see note, bottom of page)
To introduce you to the complex
city of Baghdad, familiarize yourself with this map of Baghdad
administrative neighborhoods and districts, taken from The
Institute for the Study Of War. It illustrates the complexity,
modernity, and the density of the city which has been host to an
ongoing war for more than seven years. Click the map to take you to the
full-size version.
*Our use of the word ‘deaths’ rather than ‘casualties’ is deliberate. This is because a ‘casualty’ in the military sense of the word is defined as “a member of the armed forces lost to service through death...” We find this problematic because civilians have no relation to the armed forces, and therefore their deaths should be seen as murders or killings and not a consequence of war.





