Throughout this project, I have encountered many problems and
dilemmas. However, from the rudimentary analysis of tides on water
pollution movement, you can see how tidal movement influence the
suspended water pollution. Furthermore, depending on the location, the
released pollution may only travel in certain area such as point source
#6, where one can deduce that the concentration of the pollutants may
be greater than others. It more or less run along the general
perception of how things go under the influences of tides. However, as
demonstrated by this project, what was attempted is a rough
approximation. There are other factors to be considered like wind
vectors and a more complex tidal movements than the simple
in-and-out pattern. In addition, the strength of tides are not the same
with tides being stronger in full moon events.
In my methodology, only least-cost paths were used. No other
permuation of possible paths were seen. As a result , in comparing the
flows for low tide and high tide, the network of paths look eerily
similar. In reality, we know that nature is more random and the
polltuion may go a similar but different route. An attempt was made to
find these other permutations but this failed. Along with this, in the
project, the nature of the pollution is suspended or at the bottom of
False Creek. More would have been done if a cost surface could have
been made for water-bourne pollutants. However, this would
have
llikely required wind data which I do not have. Furthermore, wind data
itself would be likely more variable than tidal currents.
There were problems with the data. In the
hydrolographic
maps, I found two versions. One from 1964 and the other from 1989.
Despite being closer to the time of this industrial activity, the 1964
map was not chosen under the premise that it did not match the
general shape of the local areas layer from the City of Vancouver. A
few years after the 1964 map, a medium portion of the eastern
end
of False Creek was covered over. In order to be more consistent , the
1989 map was chosen.
In addition, I had some doubts with
the fire insurance plans. During my research, the fire insurance maps
were large sheets of slightly mould canvas. Due to the cost of mapping
perhaps, new maps were not made. Instead, they reprinted the maps from
1948 and made changes to it. Buildings that no longer existed were
scratched out with a pencil. Changes in the buildings via tenants or
rennovations were made by drawing it on a separate piece of paper and
sticking it on top of the original building. Some canvas
were patchworks.